You don’t plan for a situation like this. One phone call, a knock at the door—suddenly you’re facing charges, and everything changes. It’s confusing, it’s overwhelming, and time isn’t on your side. Before anything else, you need to figure out who’s going to stand with you in court.
That choice matters. Some lawyers handle criminal cases once in a while. Others make it their focus. In Michigan, where laws and local court systems have their own rhythms, the difference shows.
This article breaks down what to look for and what to avoid when hiring a criminal defense attorney. If you’re already weighing your options, the Law Office of James Fillmore is available to talk through the next steps.
Know What You’re Dealing With
Criminal charges are serious, no matter the details. Even a first-time offense can throw your life into chaos. You might be thinking about court, your job, your family—everything feels uncertain. In Michigan, the legal process isn’t always straightforward. Each county does things its own way, and outcomes can vary depending on where your case lands. That’s why you need someone who knows how these courts actually work.
Find Someone Who Knows the Territory
You want a lawyer who handles criminal cases all the time, not one who dabbles in everything. Local experience matters here. Courtrooms have their own pace, their own players. Someone like James Fillmore, who works directly with Michigan’s criminal courts, brings the kind of knowledge that only comes from doing this every day. That includes understanding the people involved, from judges to prosecutors, and knowing how to adjust a defense to fit the environment.
Listen to What Others Have Experienced
Before hiring a lawyer, it helps to hear what past clients have to say. You can learn a lot from reviews, both the good and the bad. Look for feedback on how they handle communication, how responsive they are, and whether clients felt supported throughout the case. If you can, speak to someone who has worked with them. And during your own consultation, ask questions that give you a better sense of how they operate.
Pay Attention to How They Talk to You
When you meet with a lawyer, notice how they speak. Are they listening to your concerns or giving rehearsed answers? Do they explain things clearly, or leave you more confused? You should feel like the lawyer understands your situation and respects your time. Legal terms might be new to you, but that doesn’t mean the conversation has to feel complicated or cold. A good attorney will keep things clear and honest.
Ask the Right Questions Up Front
Before you agree to anything, you deserve straight answers. What kind of strategy would they use for your case? What happens next? What will it cost, and what’s included in those fees? You’re hiring someone to guide you through a high-stress process, and they should be ready to tell you how they plan to do that. At the Law Office of James Fillmore, you can expect a conversation that’s honest and to the point, not vague or full of guesswork.
Go With the Person You Trust
Credentials and experience are important, but they’re not everything. After you’ve met with a lawyer, take a step back and ask yourself how it felt. Did they take time to understand your situation? Were they upfront about what to expect? You’re not just looking for someone with the right qualifications, you’re looking for someone you’re comfortable working with. That part matters more than people realize.
Don’t Wait Too Long to Act
The earlier you bring in an attorney, the more options you’ll have. Waiting might seem easier in the moment, especially if you’re unsure of what’s happening or hoping things might blow over. But delay can cost you. Evidence can disappear, witnesses can be harder to reach, and the court might move faster than expected. A lawyer can step in early to protect your rights, talk to prosecutors, and keep the process from getting away from you. Starting sooner gives you more control and better footing. It’s one of the smartest moves you can make.
Get Started When You’re Ready
When you’re facing charges in Michigan, it helps to have someone in your corner early on. If you want to talk to a lawyer who focuses on criminal defense and understands how Michigan courts operate, reach out to the Law Office of James Fillmore. The consultation is confidential, and it’s a chance to figure out what the next move should be—no pressure, no commitments, just answers when you need them.
